Magic artwork$178€158today

Is a Fifth Dawn bundle worth opening?

Magic. 6 packs of 15 cards. Released 4 June 2004. Prices from 15 October 2026.

Cardmarket today

$177.60€158.46

Lowest listing
$160.27€143
Per pack
$29.60€26.41

Keep it sealed$30€27 of cards inside, after selling costs

Estimated contents: nobody has published measured pull rates for this box yet, so we use those of boxes with the same pack layout. Treat the numbers as a rough guide.

See the mathPrice history

Why we'd keep it sealed

The cards inside are worth $30€27 after selling costs. The box costs $178€158.

On average you lose $147€131 per box. Buying the singles you want is cheaper.

These pull rates are estimates, but the box's value hardly depends on them: it's likely between $30€27 and $31€28.

If you opened 100 boxes

  • 0 make money
  • 100 lose money

A typical box is worth $28€25. 1 in 10 boxes is worth $51€46 or more, and 1 in 10 is worth $13€11 or less.

Fifth Dawn EV: the math, per box

From the price of every card to what you'd actually keep.

Per box of 6 packs

Box price on Cardmarket
$178€158
Cards inside, at market prices
$48€43
Selling costs and bulk
−$17−€16
Cards inside, after selling costs
$30€27
Compared with the box price
−$147−€131

From 100,000 simulated boxes. Selling costs: 5% fee, $0.28€0.25 per card sold, cards under $1.12€1.00 go to bulk at $0.01€0.01.

Cards inside, at market prices
The average value of everything in a box, with each card at its price on Cardmarket today.
Selling costs and bulk
Cardmarket's fee and postage for every card worth selling. Cheap cards go to bulk for a few cents.
Cards inside, after selling costs
What an average box puts in your pocket once everything is sold.
Compared with the box price
Plus means the average box is worth more than it costs. Minus means it's worth less.

What the box costs

Today's price on Cardmarket, and how the box price and the cards inside have moved.

Cardmarket today
$177.60€158.46$29.60€26.41 per pack
Lowest listing
$160.27€143

The price history starts on the day live prices switch on, and grows by one point a day.

What 100,000 simulated boxes were worth

Every box is different. This is how the value of each simulated box came out, after selling costs.

Value of 100,000 simulated boxes100 of every 100 simulated boxes were worth less than the box price of $178.Box price $178€158Lose money05101520$50$100$150€50€100€150Boxes out of 100Under $9: 5 of 100 boxes$9 to $15: 10 of 100 boxes$15 to $21: 15 of 100 boxes$21 to $26: 16 of 100 boxes$26 to $32: 14 of 100 boxes$32 to $38: 12 of 100 boxes$38 to $43: 9 of 100 boxes$43 to $49: 7 of 100 boxes$49 to $54: 4 of 100 boxes$54 to $60: 3 of 100 boxes$60 to $66: 2 of 100 boxes$66 to $71: 1 in 87 boxes$71 to $77: 1 in 151 boxes$77 to $82: 1 in 220 boxes$82 to $88: 1 in 433 boxes$88 to $94: 1 in 546 boxes$94 to $99: 1 in 1,124 boxes$99 to $105: 1 in 1,852 boxes$105 to $110: 1 in 2,632 boxes$110 to $116: 1 in 4,000 boxes$116 to $122: 1 in 6,667 boxes$122 to $127: 1 in 100,000 boxes$127 to $133: 1 in 33,333 boxes$133 to $138: 1 in 100,000 boxes$138 to $144: 0 of 100 boxes$144 to $150: 1 in 100,000 boxes$150 to $155: 1 in 100,000 boxes$155 to $161: 0 of 100 boxes$161 to $166: 0 of 100 boxes$166 to $172: 0 of 100 boxes$172 to $178: 0 of 100 boxes$178 to $183: 0 of 100 boxes$183 to $189: 0 of 100 boxes$189 to $194: 0 of 100 boxesValue of 100,000 simulated boxes100 of every 100 simulated boxes were worth less than the box price of $178.Box price $178€158Lose money05101520$50$100$150€50€100€150Boxes out of 100Under $9: 5 of 100 boxes$9 to $15: 10 of 100 boxes$15 to $21: 15 of 100 boxes$21 to $26: 16 of 100 boxes$26 to $32: 14 of 100 boxes$32 to $38: 12 of 100 boxes$38 to $43: 9 of 100 boxes$43 to $49: 7 of 100 boxes$49 to $54: 4 of 100 boxes$54 to $60: 3 of 100 boxes$60 to $66: 2 of 100 boxes$66 to $71: 1 in 87 boxes$71 to $77: 1 in 151 boxes$77 to $82: 1 in 220 boxes$82 to $88: 1 in 433 boxes$88 to $94: 1 in 546 boxes$94 to $99: 1 in 1,124 boxes$99 to $105: 1 in 1,852 boxes$105 to $110: 1 in 2,632 boxes$110 to $116: 1 in 4,000 boxes$116 to $122: 1 in 6,667 boxes$122 to $127: 1 in 100,000 boxes$127 to $133: 1 in 33,333 boxes$133 to $138: 1 in 100,000 boxes$138 to $144: 0 of 100 boxes$144 to $150: 1 in 100,000 boxes$150 to $155: 1 in 100,000 boxes$155 to $161: 0 of 100 boxes$161 to $166: 0 of 100 boxes$166 to $172: 0 of 100 boxes$172 to $178: 0 of 100 boxes$178 to $183: 0 of 100 boxes$183 to $189: 0 of 100 boxes$189 to $194: 0 of 100 boxes
Each bar covers $6€5 of box value. Bars right of the line are boxes worth at least what you paid.
Show as a table
Box valueBoxes out of 100Result
Under $9€85 of 100Lose money
$9€8 to $15€1310 of 100Lose money
$15€13 to $21€1815 of 100Lose money
$21€18 to $26€2316 of 100Lose money
$26€23 to $32€2814 of 100Lose money
$32€28 to $38€3312 of 100Lose money
$38€33 to $43€389 of 100Lose money
$43€38 to $49€437 of 100Lose money
$49€43 to $54€484 of 100Lose money
$54€48 to $60€533 of 100Lose money
$60€53 to $66€582 of 100Lose money
$66€58 to $71€631 in 87Lose money
$71€63 to $77€681 in 151Lose money
$77€68 to $82€731 in 220Lose money
$82€73 to $88€781 in 433Lose money
$88€78 to $94€831 in 546Lose money
$94€83 to $99€881 in 1,124Lose money
$99€88 to $105€931 in 1,852Lose money
$105€93 to $110€981 in 2,632Lose money
$110€98 to $116€1031 in 4,000Lose money
$116€103 to $122€1081 in 6,667Lose money
$122€108 to $127€1131 in 100,000Lose money
$127€113 to $133€1181 in 33,333Lose money
$133€118 to $138€1231 in 100,000Lose money
$138€123 to $144€1280 of 100Lose money
$144€128 to $150€1331 in 100,000Lose money
$150€133 to $155€1381 in 100,000Lose money
$155€138 to $161€1430 of 100Lose money
$161€143 to $166€1480 of 100Lose money
$166€148 to $172€1530 of 100Lose money
$172€153 to $178€1580 of 100Lose money
$178€158 to $183€1630 of 100Make money
$183€163 to $189€1680 of 100Make money
$189€168 to $194€1730 of 100Make money

Where the value comes from

The average box, split by card type. Most of the value often sits in cards you'll rarely see.

Card typeHow many per boxAverage card after selling costsAdds to the box
Rare5.9 per box5.9 per box$2.36€2.10$14€12
Uncommon18 per box18 per box$0.67€0.60$12€11
Common65 per box65 per box$0.03€0.02$1.66€1.48
Foil uncommon1 in 3.9 boxes1 in 3.9 boxes$4.64€4.14$1.19€1.06
Foil rare1 in 12 boxes1 in 12 boxes$10.21€9.11$0.87€0.78
Foil common1 in 1.1 boxes1 in 1.1 boxes$0.91€0.81$0.86€0.77
Total$30€27

Chance of a big pull

How often a box has at least one of the rarest cards.

Show as a table
Card typeBoxes with at least oneOn averageBoxes for one specific card
Foil rare8 of 1001 in 12 boxes642

If card prices fall

Prices often drop in the weeks after a set comes out. This is the same box with cheaper cards and the same box price.

Card pricesCards inside, after costsCompared with the boxBoxes that lose moneyVerdict
Today's prices$30€27−$147−€131100 of 100Keep it sealed
25% lower$22€19−$156−€139100 of 100Keep it sealed
50% lower$14€12−$164−€146100 of 100Keep it sealed
75% lower$6€6−$171−€153100 of 100Keep it sealed

Fifth Dawn pull rates

Where each number comes from, and how sure we are. Sources checked on 14 October 2026. This box's own pull rates haven't been measured, so these come from boxes with the same pack layout, with extra uncertainty added.

Card typeHow oftenLikely rangeBased on
Common slots, 11 per pack
Foil common1 in 1.1 boxes1 in 1.9 boxes to 1.7 per boxEstimate, Wikipedia: List of Magic: The Gathering sets (premium card rate 1 in 100 cards from Urza's Legacy, 1 in 70 from Torment, 1 in 56 from Tenth Edition; release dates)
Common65 per boxThe rest of the slot
Uncommon slots, 3 per pack
Foil uncommon1 in 3.9 boxes1 in 2.2 to 7.0 boxesEstimate, Wikipedia: List of Magic: The Gathering sets (premium card rate 1 in 100 cards from Urza's Legacy, 1 in 70 from Torment, 1 in 56 from Tenth Edition; release dates)
Uncommon18 per boxThe rest of the slot
Rare slot, 1 per pack
Foil rare1 in 12 boxes1 in 6.5 to 21 boxesEstimate, Wikipedia: List of Magic: The Gathering sets (premium card rate 1 in 100 cards from Urza's Legacy, 1 in 70 from Torment, 1 in 56 from Tenth Edition; release dates)
Rare5.9 per boxThe rest of the slot

Most valuable Fifth Dawn cards

The 30 most valuable cards in the set, and what you'd keep after selling one.

CardCard typeCardmarket priceAfter selling costs
Krark-Clan Ironworks (foil)Foil uncommon$50.48€45.04$47.68€42.54
Mycosynth Golem (foil)Foil rare$49.88€44.50$47.10€42.03
Grinding Station (foil)Foil uncommon$49.49€44.16$46.74€41.70
Engineered Explosives (foil)Foil rare$45.80€40.86$43.23€38.57
Crucible of Worlds (foil)Foil rare$40.32€35.97$38.02€33.92
Auriok Champion (foil)Foil rare$39.19€34.97$36.95€32.97
Clock of Omens (foil)Foil uncommon$32.31€28.83$30.42€27.14
Beacon of Immortality (foil)Foil rare$30.52€27.23$28.71€25.62
Staff of Domination (foil)Foil rare$27.34€24.39$25.69€22.92
Doubling Cube (foil)Foil rare$25.76€22.98$24.19€21.58
Vedalken Orrery (foil)Foil rare$24.19€21.58$22.70€20.25
Plunge into Darkness (foil)Foil rare$23.53€20.99$22.07€19.69
Eternal Witness (foil)Foil uncommon$23.40€20.88$21.95€19.59
Crucible of WorldsRare$22.81€20.35$21.39€19.08
Mycosynth GolemRare$22.80€20.34$21.38€19.07
Silent Arbiter (foil)Foil rare$21.25€18.96$19.91€17.76
Fist of Suns (foil)Foil rare$20.87€18.62$19.55€17.44
Artificer's Intuition (foil)Foil rare$20.35€18.16$19.06€17.00
Summoning Station (foil)Foil rare$18.02€16.08$16.84€15.03
Paradise Mantle (foil)Foil uncommon$17.94€16.01$16.77€14.96
Steelshaper's Gift (foil)Foil uncommon$16.79€14.98$15.67€13.98
Salvaging Station (foil)Foil rare$14.34€12.79$13.34€11.90
Beacon of Tomorrows (foil)Foil rare$13.91€12.41$12.93€11.54
Reversal of Fortune (foil)Foil rare$12.87€11.48$11.94€10.66
Doubling CubeRare$12.43€11.09$11.53€10.29
Helm of Kaldra (foil)Foil rare$11.87€10.59$11.00€9.81
Krark-Clan IronworksUncommon$11.59€10.34$10.73€9.57
Blasting Station (foil)Foil uncommon$11.53€10.29$10.68€9.53
Staff of DominationRare$11.17€9.97$10.34€9.22
Battered Golem (foil)Foil common$10.69€9.54$9.88€8.81

How we work this out

We price every card at its Cardmarket market value, take off the selling costs above, and open 100,000 virtual boxes slot by slot using the pull rates in the table. The verdict compares the cards with the box price and checks how often a box loses money.

Read the full method

More Magic boxes

All Magic boxes