Magic Prophecy vs Nemesis booster box: which is worth opening?

Neither is worth opening at today's prices, but Prophecy comes closer: its cards are worth 40% of its price after selling costs, against 26% for Nemesis.

Prices from October 15, 2026, updated daily.

Side by side

Prophecy booster boxNemesis booster box
VerdictKeep it sealedKeep it sealed
Box price today$969€865$1,028€917
Cards inside, after selling costs$385€343$267€239
Cards ÷ price40%26%
Boxes that lose moneymore than 99 of 100 boxesmore than 99 of 100 boxes
A typical box (median)$369€329$243€217
Rarest pullFoil rare: 30 of 100 boxesFoil rare: 30 of 100 boxes
Packs36 packs of 15 cards36 packs of 15 cards
ReleasedJune 5, 2000February 14, 2000

The two boxes

How we work this out

Both boxes are worked out the same way: today's card prices, selling costs taken off, and simulated boxes to see how often one loses money. Read the full method

Best Magic boxes to open now