Best Magic booster boxes to open right now

Every box we track, ranked by what its cards are worth after selling costs against today's box price. Updated October 15, 2026.

The best Magic box to open today is the Magic The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth Draft Booster box: $445€397 of cards after selling costs for a $329€293 box, and 11 of 100 boxes lose money.

Every Magic box, ranked

#	Box	Verdict	Box price	Cards, after costs	Cards ÷ price	Boxes that lose money
1	The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth Draft Booster box	Rip it	$329€293	$445€397	136%	11 of 100
2	Commander Masters Set Booster box	Rip it	$542€484	$726€648	134%	6 of 100
3	Marvel's Spider-Man Collector Booster box	Toss-up	$378€338	$487€435	129%	80 of 100
4	The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth Set Booster box	Toss-up	$358€319	$380€339	106%	44 of 100
5	Reality Fracture Collector Booster box	Toss-up	$379€338	$398€355	105%	58 of 100
6	Foundations Play Booster box	Toss-up	$143€128	$150€134	105%	46 of 100
7	Ravnica Remastered Draft Booster box	Toss-up	$253€225	$255€227	101%	51 of 100
8	Modern Horizons Draft Booster box	Toss-up	$270€241	$271€242	100%	53 of 100
9	Modern Horizons 3 Play Booster box	Toss-up	$307€274	$302€269	98%	56 of 100
10	Unfinity Collector Booster box	Toss-up	$380€339	$370€330	97%	56 of 100
11	Final Fantasy Collector Booster box	Toss-up	$1,260€1,124	$1,174€1,048	93%	91 of 100
12	Final Fantasy Play Booster box	Keep it sealed	$187€167	$166€148	89%	79 of 100
13	Unstable Draft Booster box	Keep it sealed	$133€119	$118€105	88%	87 of 100
14	Assassin's Creed booster box	Keep it sealed	$159€141	$136€121	86%	76 of 100
15	Murders at Karlov Manor Play Booster box	Keep it sealed	$147€132	$125€111	85%	74 of 100
16	Outlaws of Thunder Junction Play Booster box	Keep it sealed	$155€139	$130€116	84%	76 of 100
17	Zendikar Rising Draft Booster box	Keep it sealed	$129€115	$108€96	84%	77 of 100
18	Modern Horizons 3 Collector Booster box	Keep it sealed	$823€734	$685€611	83%	85 of 100
19	Eternal Masters Draft Booster box	Keep it sealed	$377€336	$301€269	80%	84 of 100
20	Conspiracy Draft Booster box	Keep it sealed	$178€159	$142€127	80%	83 of 100
21	Marvel Super Heroes Collector Booster box	Keep it sealed	$370€330	$293€261	79%	92 of 100
22	Double Masters 2022 Draft Booster box	Keep it sealed	$376€335	$297€265	79%	80 of 100
23	Commander Masters Draft Booster box	Keep it sealed	$479€428	$376€336	79%	88 of 100
24	Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate Draft Booster box	Keep it sealed	$349€312	$271€242	78%	86 of 100
25	Masters 25 Draft Booster box	Keep it sealed	$248€221	$187€167	75%	92 of 100
26	Kaldheim Draft Booster box	Keep it sealed	$158€141	$119€106	75%	86 of 100
27	Duskmourn: House of Horror Play Booster box	Keep it sealed	$166€148	$125€111	75%	91 of 100
28	Murders at Karlov Manor bundle	Keep it sealed	$42€37	$31€28	75%	74 of 100
29	Streets of New Capenna Collector Booster box	Keep it sealed	$257€229	$192€171	75%	90 of 100
30	Time Spiral Remastered Draft Booster box	Keep it sealed	$250€223	$186€166	75%	89 of 100

Worth opening

The cards are worth more than the box after selling costs, and most boxes come out ahead.

Magic The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earthDraft Boosters Rip it $445€397 of cards for a $329€293 box 11 of 100 boxes lose money Released June 23, 2023. Estimated odds
Magic Commander MastersSet Boosters Rip it $726€648 of cards for a $542€484 box 6 of 100 boxes lose money Released August 4, 2023

Toss-ups

Close to break-even, or only worth it if you land a big hit.

Keep these sealed

The least value inside for the price.

More rankings

Each box's cards are priced at today's market value, selling costs come off, and simulated boxes show how often one loses money. Read the full method